5 Comments
User's avatar
Brad Kyle's avatar

You accurately identified the vast difference in responses to Roy in the UK and US, Mitchell! I was in radio in '75, and have never seen the "HQ" title or jacket art on the UK/Harvest release! But, the "When an Old...." on Chrysalis is very recognizable to this stateside cat. In the late '70s, too, that's the record/jacket we sold in my record store!

It's been my experience (and I think US chart placement/sales bear me out) that Roy never really got any traction in the states. I know I never played him on the 2 FM rock stations I was at, and I can't recall personally ever selling any of his albums! I used to read about him a lot on the imported NMEs/Melody Makers/Sounds tabs I'd buy (a week later, of course, after shipment) at my local newsstand, and wondered what he sounded like!

Even though I had promos aplenty on each of his '70s Chrysalis catalog items, I don't recall much of what he sounded like (I must've auditioned each one at least a bit), but I think my personal noncommittal response was echoed, by and large, by radio folk and record-buyers. To our detriment, I'm sure, but, despite not being a household name, I DO know he's respected and heralded by many here in the states!

Add Roy's name to the list of other talented Brit/UK-area singer/songwriters who are roundly respected, but are largely unknown in the US: John Martyn, Nick Drake, Bert Jansch, John Renbourn, and probably more!

Mitchell Stirling's avatar

I imagine Harper is probably more known in the US for his namecheck on Led Zeppelin III and vocals on Pink Floyd's 'Have A Cigar'.

Brad Kyle's avatar

To quote Fonzie, "Exact-a-mundo!"👍

Challenge 69's avatar

So, cricket referencing songs are pretty few and far between; there's this, and 10CC's 'I Don't Like Cricket', but surely the winner (by 22 yards!) has to be Half Man, Half Biscuit's 'Fuckin' 'ell it's Fred Titmus'!

Mitchell Stirling's avatar

Yes, there was a concise period in 1978 when Harper's song had just been re-released as a single and 'Dreadlock Holiday' was about to be released that two could have been getting radio play. Other than HMHB, I think that The Duckworth-Lewis Method in 2009 is the next significant port of call.